Smothering Tithe Gives White Too Much Treasure in Rosewater’s Eyes
Mark Rosewater also rejected restricting its Treasures to white mana as a way to make the card fit.
Multiverse Dispatch · 19 November 2026, 20:55 · 3 min read

Mark Rosewater called Smothering Tithe a design mistake on November 18, 2026, telling a fan who asked about redesigning it that he would simply never have made it. His objection was white’s access to Treasure: “White isn’t supposed to be good at making treasure.”
In related Blogatog answers that day, Rosewater drew a distinction between allowing to collect Treasure through taxes and allowing it to control Treasure production. The payment option has to be realistic, and he rejected both Gleaming Splendor’s more restricted production and a proposed version of Smothering Tithe whose tokens could produce only
.
A Tax Needs a Real Choice
Asked on November 18, 2026, whether Gleaming Splendor also failed his test, Rosewater explained that should have very little access to Treasure. He identified the practical limit on the tax exception:
We allow a little of it as a tax, but the opponent must have a real choice of whether or not to pay the tax. If it’s something the player realistically can’t pay much of the time, it’s a break.
Smothering Tithe puts that problem into play whenever an opponent draws a card. Its payment competes with whatever that opponent needs to cast that turn, and each additional draw presents another payment. An opponent who draws with no mana available gives its controller a Treasure without making a spending decision.

Smothering Tithe
Enchantment
Whenever an opponent draws a card, that player may pay . If the player doesn't, you create a Treasure token. (It's an artifact with "
, Sacrifice this token: Add one mana of any color.")
$54.08 · €38.79 · 0.03 tix
Rosewater had addressed the other side of that choice on November 8, 2026. When a fan asked about Monologue Tax, he said opponents must have a true choice not to perform the taxed action, giving a trigger on every land play as an unacceptable example because avoiding it would be too onerous. His test therefore concerns both the ability to pay and the ability to decline the action.
Fewer Treasures Do Not Fix the Objection
Gleaming Splendor costs and makes Treasure when an opponent draws their second card each turn, a narrower trigger than Smothering Tithe’s. But its
activated ability lets two target players each draw a card. Its controller can choose an opponent who has already drawn once that turn and cause the Treasure ability to trigger.
That control was Rosewater’s stated objection in his November 18, 2026, answer about Gleaming Splendor. He said he personally would not make cards like it because they let control Treasure production. Making fewer Treasures was not enough to satisfy his color-pie standard.
Another fan proposed limiting the mana from Smothering Tithe’s Treasures to on November 18, 2026. Rosewater answered “No” when asked whether that would put the card within the color pie. Removing the tokens’ ability to fix other colors would still leave the underlying production problem.
White’s Taxing Has an Established Limit
Wizards’ mechanical color-pie update, published on October 18, 2021, lists taxing as primary in and secondary in
. That gives
a strong claim to imposing added costs on opponents’ activities, but Rosewater’s Treasure exception has long been narrower.
In his New Capenna design account of April 25, 2022, Rosewater explained that is not a main Treasure-making color because it should not be good at splashing other colors. An early version of Extraction Specialist produced Treasure through its controller’s own actions and was judged outside the color pie. He allowed the tax exception only for actions opponents could truly opt out of.
That distinction also fits his account of white’s philosophy, published on July 13, 2015: uses rules and laws to guide behavior toward the group’s interests. We agree with the boundary he draws here because a tax that opponents routinely cannot avoid functions as dependable resource production rather than a meaningful incentive to change their play.
Sources
- Card: Smothering Tithe
- Card: Gleaming Splendor
- Magic: The Gathering (Making Magic) — The Great White Way Revisited, 13 July 2015
- Magic: The Gathering (Making Magic) — Mechanical Color Pie 2021 Changes, 18 October 2021
- Magic: The Gathering (Making Magic) — Word on the Streets of New Capenna, Part 2, 25 April 2022
- Page: if smothering tithe was a design mistake wouldn't...
- Page: Do you consider Smothering Tithe to be a design...
- Page: If smothering tithe's treasures could only make...
- Page: You have gone on record saying that white should...




Comments
No comment yet.