Ixalan's First Set Made a Theme Shift Easier for Lost Caverns
Rosewater called Lost Caverns of Ixalan a creative success and contrasted its reception with Murders of Karlov Manor.
Multiverse Dispatch · 21 November 2026, 09:04
Since our November 19 article on Rosewater’s preference for new worlds to explore new horror territory, he has added a qualification. A fan asked whether Lost Caverns of Ixalan succeeded creatively by deepening Ixalan and exploring a new subgenre. In a November 20 Blogatog reply, Rosewater said:
It was, but it was building on a world that hadn't mechanically gone well the first time out, so shifting themes was less problematic.
He contrasted Ixalan with Murders of Karlov Manor, where one of the biggest complaints was too little guild presence and a set that did not feel Ravnica-y enough. Rosewater did not name which mechanics had not gone well in Ixalan’s first outing; he said that reception made a thematic shift less problematic.




Comments
No comment yet.