Rosewater Says a Triple Replacement Could Miss Magic’s Doubling Effects
Doubling Season and Mana Reflection both double without using the word “double.”
Multiverse Dispatch · 21 November 2026, 22:10
Mark Rosewater said a rule that turns doubling into tripling would face a wording problem, in response to a fan’s hypothetical on November 19. Many effects that double things do not use “double,” he wrote. Doubling Season and Anointed Procession create “twice that many” tokens, while Doubling Season also applies that wording to counters. Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider uses it for counters, and Mana Reflection makes a tapped-for-mana permanent produce “twice as much” mana. The doubling effects already use several templates.
Rosewater also said a replacement word needs to have only one function, but did not specify which different uses of “double” concern him. One possible illustration is the phrase “double the number” on Mossborn Hydra compared with the keyword “double strike” on Boros Charm; those are examples, not ones Rosewater named. He said text replacement can work, but the post is a hypothetical rules question, not an announcement that Wizards has tested the card.




Comments
No comment yet.