Multiverse Dispatch
Design · In brief

Sorcery-Speed Counterspells Are Hard to Cost

Mark Rosewater says unusual casting conditions can confuse players as well as complicate a card’s cost.

Multiverse Dispatch · 15 November 2026, 15:34

ShareImage

On November 7, a fan asked Mark Rosewater on Blogatog whether a counterspell restricted to sorcery timing could become unusually powerful if players had a way around that restriction. Rosewater warned that cards that “don’t work normally” confuse players and are “super hard to cost.” The design has to make both the workaround and the spell’s power clear.

Mystic DenialAs a precedent, Rosewater cited a card he called “Mystical Denial” from original Portal, which had no instants; he described it as “very ‘cheaty’.” Scryfall lists Mystic Denial as an instant. Another fan mentioned a Secret Lair Circular Logic misprinted as a sorcery, saying its madness cost still worked with that timing, but Rosewater’s follow-up focused on the Portal example.

ShareImage

Sources

Comments

No comment yet.

We keep the name you give and your comment, nothing else: no email, no address.

More Design