Multiverse Dispatch
Design · In brief

A Land-and-Nonland Experiment Played Worse, Rosewater Says

Rosewater said he tried the experiment years ago.

Multiverse Dispatch · 15 November 2026, 19:49

ShareImage

Asked whether he had tested a separate land deck and nonland deck, Mark Rosewater said he had tried the idea years ago. In his Blogatog answer on November 15, he called it “significantly worse”: “Controlling exactly when you get mana does not lead to better gameplay.”

In a separate Blogatog answer on November 3, Rosewater said abandoning Magic’s core resource system is seldom a good idea, though a handful of cards might use another one. For players who want more predictable mana, the experiment’s verdict is clear: making mana timing more controllable did not improve gameplay in Rosewater’s test.

ShareImage

Sources

Comments

No comment yet.

We keep the name you give and your comment, nothing else: no email, no address.

More Design